اخبار العرب-كندا 24: الجمعة 10 مايو 2024 11:41 صباحاً
Settlements have been reached in lawsuits against Bathurst and its police force over the shooting death of Michel Vienneau in 2015 after police got a false Crime Stoppers tip he was trafficking drugs.
The cases concluded in recent months in Bathurst's Court of King's Bench without going to trial.
The settlements bring to a close one of the final proceedings stemming from Vienneau's shooting death on Jan. 12, 2015, while leaving the Bathurst train station with his common-law spouse, Annick Basque.
Basque filed a lawsuit on behalf of her two daughters in 2015 against the city, the police force, and officers Mathieu Boudreau and Patrick Bulger, claiming damages and loss of income because of the 51-year-old Tracadie businessman's death.
A second lawsuit against the city alleged she was arrested forcibly and without reason immediately after the shooting.
Basque's lawyer, Charles Leblanc, told Radio-Canada the financial settlement between Basque and the city is subject to a confidentiality agreement.
In the case involving her daughters, court documents show a settlement amount totalling $70,000. Each daughter will receive $25,000, with the lawyer paid $20,000 to cover legal costs, the documents show.
The Via Rail train station in Bathurst was cordoned off for a week following the January 2015 shooting death of Michel Vienneau. (Bridget Yard/CBC)
The municipality wouldn't comment on the settlements, including how the municipality will cover the settlement costs or how much it has spent on legal costs over nine years.
"It is the norm for the City of Bathurst to not comment on legal matters," Luc Foulem, a spokesperson for the city said in an email Friday. "The same approach applies to this particular situation."
Details of the shooting had emerged through a series of court and other proceedings over the years, including criminal charges against the officers, a coroner's inquest, and a hearing about whether the officers should be fired.
Those proceedings painted a picture of a rushed police operation in response to anonymous Crime Stoppers tips alleging Vienneau was trafficking drugs on a passenger train that was due to arrive in Bathurst that morning.
Mathieu Boudreau, left, and Patrick Bulger shown in 2019 during a hearing about whether they should keep their jobs. (Shane Magee/CBC )
In reality, Vienneau and Basque were returning from a weekend trip to Montreal to watch a hockey game. An RCMP investigation after the shooting found no evidence of drug trafficking.
The tips were received that morning by a team of officers from the region's police forces tasked with surveillance and intelligence gathering related to drugs and organized crime.
Bulger and Boudreau, Bathurst officers, were part of that team who rushed to the train station in the hopes of intercepting the couple.
They wore plain clothes and worked in unmarked vehicles with hidden police lights.
Vienneau placed a suitcase in the trunk of his vehicle and started to drive away from the train station. Boudreau and Bulger moved to stop him, getting out of the unmarked car and drawing their pistols.
Evidence heard at a discipline hearing for the officers in 2019 indicated that Vienneau drove his car into the police car and kept driving toward Bulger.
Basque later testified that they panicked, thinking about a recent terrorist attack in Paris.
Bulger testified he was hit by Vienneau's car and pinned against a snowbank. Boudreau, who testified he feared for his partner's life, then fired four times at Vienneau. He died of a gunshot wound.
The officers, in a statement of defence filed in one of the cases, said they were acting in self-defence.
Boudreau and Bulger were charged with manslaughter. The case was dropped after a preliminary inquiry, held to test the Crown's evidence before a case can move ahead to trial.
An arbitrator ruled in 2019 that Boudreau and Bulger did not violate a police code of conduct and could keep their jobs.
A coroner's inquest jury in 2021 issued five recommendations to avoid similar deaths in the future, touching on how police are equipped. One recommendation was that officers should wear something clearly labelled "police" when they try to stop someone.
In the years since the shooting, a major unanswered question has been the source and motivation for the false tips.
A coroner who presided over the 2021 inquest said they attempted to have someone from Crime Stoppers testify, but courts have ruled the program's information should be kept confidential.
Documents obtained by CBC News revealed the RCMP considered an investigation into the source of the tips, but police later said officers don't know the identity of the person who submitted the tips.
تم ادراج الخبر والعهده على المصدر، الرجاء الكتابة الينا لاي توضبح - برجاء اخبارنا بريديا عن خروقات لحقوق النشر للغير
